this blog is girtby.net

Posted
29 August 2007

Categories
linkpimpin' or something

Tags
headphones audio denon yuin meier koss audio technica

9 Comments

Strapping a Motorcycle to Your Head

A wise man once told me that he deliberately avoided cultivating expensive tastes, because they are ultimately unsatisfying unless you are uncommonly wealthy. I think this is probably good advice in general, and particularly good advice for cars, wine, cameras, and home A/V equipment. But for headphones, not so much. Sure, you get the urge to upgrade, but you won't end up mortgaging your house to do so. Although you can of course go overboard if you want to, the point of diminishing returns can be reached relatively cheaply.

Dan likes to make the analogy with motorcycles. They perform better than cars, but at a fraction of the price. This is true also of headphones versus a full-blown home Hi-Fi system. However, unlike motorcycles, headphones are more practical than their full-priced competitors. You can even carry them around!

After mildly disagreeing with Dan, I'm going to spend the rest of the article quoting and linking to him. It's a net positive, really!

The only thing you really lose with the headphone experience is that whole-body listening sensation. You don't get to feel that thump in your chest on really deep bass hits. Instead it's all in your head. Which is by no means unpleasant, just slightly different to a live performance or even a good Hi-Fi system.

In case it's not painfully obvious, this post is about headphones. It contains some recommendations and advice about specific types and models, but mainly the message I want to get across is that headphones are an inexpensive and invaluable conduit to musical satisfaction. For a few hundred measly bucks you can experience something close to musical perfection. Without even bothering the neighbours. (Although you can do that too, just by singing along...)

Yuin PK3

Yuin PK3 HeadphonesLet's start the tour at with the least expensive. These babies are a measly A$39 shipped from m'verygoodfriends at headphonic. Put bluntly, these are probably the best value of any headphone I own.

If you have an iPod, you're probably listening with the iBuds that came with it, thinking they're not too bad. And you're right, they are OK. The second gen iBuds (with the rubber sides) are fine for spoken word and are quite comfortable, and don't sound too bad if you manage to place them correctly in your ear. However in comparison to the Yuins they sound like ... well, like crap really.

Take my word for it, the Yuins are well worth the measly upgrade. You dropped a few hundred on the iPod, what about another $39 for some decent headphones?

If you've tried earbuds before and have beed disappointed, I sympathise. I was initially reluctant myself. Unlike most earbuds I have ever tried, these seem to sit really nicely in my ears and don't need fiddling with in order to get a decent seal (and hence provide very decent bass response).

Gripes? Umm, well the foam covers fall off pretty easily. Also the cables are slightly heavier than the iBuds, and hence snag on clothing more easily. Otherwise great.

These are my default carry-around headphones. The earbud form factor is light, portable, and easy to take on and off.

Just get 'em.

Koss KSC-35

Koss KSC-35 HeadphonesThese are my exercise headphones. They have individual clips which take a few seconds and a bit of practice to put on, but tend to stay put a lot better when jumping up and down (or when bent double and breathless).

These are "open" headphones which means they leak sound to the outside. This may be bad in some situations. But on the upside they also sound a lot more open, meaning that the sound is less in-your-head. I believe headphone nuts refer to this characteristic as the "soundstage" but I wouldn't stoop to such audiowanker terms. Oh, OK maybe I would.

In general the sound is probably not as good as the Yuins but there's not a lot in it. The bass response in particular is really strong but a bit muddier than I would like. By this I mean they start to sound a bit farty and boomy, particularly when the music has complicated passages of bass notes. For the money though they're great.

Koss don't make the KSC-35s any more, but have since replaced them with the KSC-75s, which probably sound better. The newer models are, I understand, a lot sturdier and more attractive than the flimsy black plastic KSC-35s. Still very reasonably priced too: A$64 shipped from headphonic (no I am not getting any commission, though I am a satisfied customer).

Sennheiser HD-555

Sennheiser HD555Another open headphone, this time a full-size pair. These are my work headphones. They are supra-aural, which means they sound like a Toyota you can wear them all day in comfort because they sit over your ears, not on them.

The sound is great too. A well "balanced" sound that doesn't seem to emphasise or hide any particular frequency range. Otherwise they are not a huge step up in sound quality from the Yuins or the Kossen.

The main advantage of the 555s is that they are comfortable and very suitable for extended listening. Also they are open, so they let in the sound of coworkers trying to get your attention (or talking about you in the next cubicle). This may be a downside though if you're trying to drown out their noise...

A$180 shipped, a good buy. See also Dan's opinion.

Audio Technica ATH-A900

Audio Technica ATH-A900 HeadphonesNow we're starting to get into the serious listening. These are a big step up in sound quality compared to all of the above.

These are closed headphones which provide pretty good isolation. They are also very comfy, with this crazy but effective "wing" system to keep them in place.

The difference in sound quality over the HD-555s is quite noticable. There is more detail all over, more precise and deep bass, more betterer treble. Or something. They're very very good.

For a long time these were my quality-listening at-home headphones. Get a glass of wine and kick back with the iTunes library on shuffle. A great way to spend a Friday night after a long week.

A$299 shipped. Well and truly worth the money in my opinion, although I am selling mine to upgrade to the Denons mentioned below, so contact me if you're interested?

Meier Corda Move amplifier

Meier Corda Move AmplifierYes, an amplifier. What's that you say? Speak up.... No! I'm not going deaf!

Here's the deal. By the time you get to spend a few hundred bucks on headphones, they will likely stop being the weakest link in your audio equipment. Instead it is almost certainly the crappy amp in your source. iPods actually have pretty good D/A converters (from what I am told anyway), but space and possibly electrical limitations prevent them from using very capable amplifiers. Headphone outputs on other devices are almost certainly afterthoughts, and so in most cases you probably want an external amplifier.

There is another possible use case for the headphone amplifier, and that is for use with high impedance headphones. Such beasts do exist, typically at the high-end, and are typically inaudible without an amplifier. None of the headphones on this page strictly require an amplifier though; they are all low impedance.

Behold the Meier Corda Move amplifier. Besides being an amplifer, it's also a USB audio device, which means that you can plug it into your laptop and not have to deal with its (probably) crappy D/A converters or amplifier. To top it all off the Move also a crossfeed filter, about which I will let Dan explain.

I was a bit sceptical about how well this unit would perform. Like I said, the iPod output isn't too bad, and neither is that from my PowerBook. But whoah. Was I amazed when plugging this thing in. So much detail, so much bass, so much ... presence. Just invites you to crank it up.

You know you have made a big step up in sound reproduction when you find yourself continually increasing the rating of everything in your iTunes library. All of your music just sounds better. The borderline three stars become fours and so on. Remember that I am very stingy with iTunes ratings, but this amplifier is rapidly curing that!

Once you have a good set of headphones, an amplifier is a great way to make them sound even better. Highly recommended. I paid US$235 directly from the source but also available from headphonic for a very reasonable A$299.

Denon AH-D2000

Denon AH-D2000 HeadphonesWhile the Move is the flavour of the month amplifier on the head-fi forums, the Denons are definitely flavour of the month headphones. My pair arrived the other day courtesy of audiocubes for a reasonable US$285, now going for an even more reasonable US$259 (dammit!), or available locally for a much less reasonable A$799 retail.

Without a doubt we are starting to approach the point of diminshing returns, but they still manage to greatly improve upon the A900s. Particularly when coupled with the Move amplifier, these sound just fantastic. So good that I want to instantly re-rate all my music with 5, no fuck it, 6 stars! OK, not really. Seriously, it's a lot of fun listening through these things. Old favourites in particular sound new again, because you hear new details that were previously hidden or at least subdued. I want to use the term "presence" again too, because it's a good one. Presence, presence, presence. Presents for your ears.

As for comfort, well these are the most comfortable headphones I have ever worn. It barely even feels like they're on.

There's a downside though. They fall apart. According to the forums it's quite common. The left ear cup dropped off mine after about 5 days. Fortunately I found the screw and was able to re-assemble them without too much hassle. Still, not a great experience.

Missing: IEM

This collection of 'phones covers most situations for which headphones are appropriate. Notably absent from this list is a headphone to handle the unique environment of the long-distance flight. If I did any regular long-distance flying (or other public transport for that matter) I would be picking up a pair of In-Ear Monitors (IEMs to the headphiles).

In the past I had used noise-cancelling headphones and I cannot recommend them lowly enough. These things are bad. The ones I had were Sonys, and quite expensive I believe at the time. But they sound atrocious. Even the noise-cancelling effect isn't that great.

The last time I flew any distance I used a pair of really cheap IEMs (also Sony) and they were so much better than the noise-cancelling monsters. I honestly can't remember the model, and they were certainly nothing special, sound-wise. Next time I travel I'll certainly pick up a new pair of IEMs. I've heard good things about the Westone UM1's and they will suffice as my recommendation for now, although I will be looking carefully at the equivalents from Shure, Ultimate Ears and Etymotic when it is time to buy.

What next?

Well of course it would be misleading of me to suggest that after dropping a grand or so I had reached headphone nirvana. But at this point I'd have to think long and hard about going for the next level up. I suspect also that the limiting factor in sound quality with my music collection right now may be in the lossy compression scheme, given that most of my library is encoded with AAC at 128kbps. But I have a plan for dealing with that, more later.

9 Comments

Posted by
Corey
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

For a cheap foray into audiophile-ism.. check out a pair of Grado SR80 headphones with a CMOY headphone amp (I like the ones made of Altoid tins.. you can get them on EBAY).

for about $130, you can have superb headphone audio.


Posted by
Alastair
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

Sounds like a good combo, Corey.

My first foray into decent headphones was courtesy of a pair of Grado SR-60s. They look very old-school, like they should be worn by the radio operator aboard a Landcaster bomber. But they sounded great.

I hear that Grados are actually hard to get outside the US nowadays and instead are marketed under the Allessandro brand, although the relationship between the two is unclear to me.

The question of CMOY-or-not really depends on the source, IMHO. I think iPods sound pretty good really and don't need amping at the lower end of the price range (meaning you're better off spending the amp money on a better set of headphones). But if you're sourcing from crappy PC audio, then sure go for the CMOY. I really like the Move because it has a USB input which allows PC audio to be bypassed completely.

And just because I haven't yet gained complete coverage of Dan's site, here is his review of the Altoids CMOY amplifier, complete with cool pictures.


Posted by
marxy
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

Thanks for a great roundup!

I get enormous pleasure out of my shortened Sure in ear headphones combined with an iPod shuffle. (I fill it randomly from my library, then delete a few and drag podcasts to listen to up the top of the list).

Also, following Dan's recommendation, I enjoy a pair of Senheiser HD212Pros but I can't bring myself to walk the streets wearing them as some do.

Intrigued about the amplifier idea.

Marxy.


Posted by
marxy
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

Oh, that reminds me, did you read about the bad effects of highly compressed audio?

Perhaps the best thing we can do is listen to audio that hasn't had the "non essential" frequencies removed.


Posted by
Alastair
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

Marxy, I for one support your stance on the Shures, they certainly don't make you look like a dork when walking the streets, unlike the full-size headphones. Maybe some hipsters can pull off the full-size headphone fashion statement, but not me.

Not too impressed with your article on compression though. Yes overly-compressed audio sounds bad, but in that case just turn up the bitrate, surely? I contend that even with the best audio equipment and the most critical listeners you'd be very hard pressed to tell the difference between a high-bitrate MP3/AAC and the uncompressed original. In fact, I was alluding to this in the final paragraph of the article; I found some software to perform blind testing of uncompressed versus compressed (i.e MP3) audio. I'm sure the results will be interesting.

When I first saw your comment I thought you were talking about a completely different type of compression; namely dynamic range compression, about which there was an excellent IEEE Spectrum article recently. I don't want to spoil it for you, but let's just say that compressed audio did not start with the digital revolution. I, for one, had no idea. Fascinating read, do not miss it.


Posted by
Aristotle Pagaltzis
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

If you liked that article, you should really read Imperfect Sound Forever, a several-thousand-word article that explores the issue in a lot of depth. And don’t miss the (much shorter) followup.

As for headphones, a really cheap option I can recommend for its tremendous oomph for the buck is a pair of AKG K-55s. I have seen not one negative review of them so far, and with good reason. Despite their emphasis on the low frequencies, they stay true to the sound rather than bombarding you with bass, so they don’t sound boomy or farty at all. At the same time treble is crisp and the middles avoid muddiness, so even though they’re closed and well-isolating ’phones, they sound rather open. Those things are one of my best purchase decisions ever. For people with small budgets, they are an excellent way to get more out of music.


Posted by
Brendan Keefe
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

A wise man once told me that he deliberately avoided cultivating expensive tastes, because they are ultimately unsatisfying unless you are uncommonly wealthy.

The late great American sportswriter, Red Smith, once said: "Never invest in anything that needs painting or feeding."

Your review almost makes me reconsider headphones. I never much liked listening to music that way. The bass thump in the chest is important, and the super-stereo effect can sometimes be annoying. Mostly, though, headphones make me jittery -- paranoid about who might be sneaking up behind me, I guess.

But now I'm in a new neighborhood, and it's a LOT louder than my last few. I may go the headphone route yet.


Posted by
marxy
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

You've prodded me to build a high quality headphone amp and I can report that it really makes a difference.

Thanks!


Posted by
marxy
2007-08-29 12:16:00 -0500
#

Ok, I went and did some tests on CD audio converted to AAC at 128 and 256Kbps. I've decoded the audio and intercut ten seconds of each and put them up as an AIF file here. Perhaps this track isn't a good choice, but to be honest I don't think I could pick between them.

Now I'm all interested in choice of music to evaluate Hi Fi components. Any recommendations?